Return to EllisWhittam Home Page        
Return to Blog Home Page        

Archive for January, 2007

Time to abolish employment law rights that are bad for UK plc?

Wednesday, January 17th, 2007

The new mantra of many politicians is “social responsibility”. Great. No doubt that will make for a more caring society.

Social responsibility can only be a good thing – but will it make for a happy and successful UK? That depends, I guess, on what makes UK plc and each of us feel happy and successful.

Call me old fashioned but I think that the success of UK plc and the happiness and success of its people are inextricably linked to the self worth, work and the wealth of its people.

And so to the point of this posting: It’s entrepreneurial employers that create and sustain jobs and income for the great majority. Employment laws that give aggrieved employees the right to claim huge compensation from employers might be just redemption in the eyes of the aggrieved employee – but shouldn’t we consider the bigger picture?

Compensation (if you are not protected by Ellis Whittam!) paid by an employer to the aggrieved employee comes straight off the bottom line – it can reduce competitiveness or is taken out of the R&D budget or creates wider job insecurity. Sometimes all three!

Sure, as a responsible society we need a set of basic laws/rights that guarantee the safety, dignity and minimum wage for all workers. But I suspect that I speak for a silent majority of employers when I say that silly amounts of compensation awarded to a sacked employee, particularly against a small employer, are bad for business, can put an entire business at risk and are bad for UK plc.

Back to that catchy mantra of modern politicians, “social responsibility”. I wonder where Mr Cameron and his socially responsible Conservatives stand on this? I’m sure that thousands of entrepreneurial employers would like to know. So, come on David, come out and tell us! Have your Conservatives turned a sharp left or do you recognise that hundreds of fluffy employment protection rights are bad for UK plc? (I’ll copy this posting to his website and let’s see if we get a reply!)

To cut to the chase - should an employee whom an entrepreneurial (job and wealth creating) employer deems to be wrong for the job have any right of comeback if he/she is sacked? Besides, if the economy is booming the sacked worker will find a new job quickly (if he/she really wants to). Are the feelings and the personal hardship suffered by an individual employee more important than the success and happiness of UK plc? It’s a tough call. What do you think?

Crazy Christmas Parties?

Tuesday, January 9th, 2007

Happy New Year and all that!

Most EW clients had a few days off over Christmas and so the office was reasonably quiet. Phew! However, the fun started quickly when most clients returned to work on 2 January.

You might be surprised (amused?) at some of the antics that go on at work Christmas parties up and down the UK! Of course, kill joys that we are here at EW, we did our best to help avoid problems (some said that we were trying to spoil the fun) by suggesting that clients put in place a Christmas Party Policy and send a memo to staff reminding them of the rules before the party! Anyway, despite our best efforts, we didn’t spoil all the fun! Here are some examples of incidents reported to us last week:

- One young girl (new to the Company) mentioned to another that she rather fancied the guy impersonating John Travolta on the dance floor. It was her bad luck that she told his wife. Tempers flared and each emptied several glasses of (good) wine over the other. The two ended up on the dance floor (rolling on it) pulling each other’s hair. The whole thing was videoed by a client guest on his mobile phone. Beat that?!

- Rather tame by comparison, a young sales person took it upon herself to throw her chocolate pudding all over her MD. He (and his DJ) were covered! Sounds like fun to me?

- An assistant manager left in charge of a restaurant on New Year’s Eve had a great party. Infact he got so drunk that he started a brawl in his own restaurant. The police were called - but were unable to take a statement from the Assistant Manager as he was too drunk to talk! Hmm!

- One company took our advice to lay on transport after the party to reduce the risk of drink driving. Unfortunately, on the way back one worker pounced upon a director and about 5 or 6 employees started fighting. The coach driver, understandably, refused to drive the party home, pulled over and the police were called to restore order!

Needless to say the EW legal team has already dealt with all of these problems, the dust has now settled, the bruises are healing and quite a few employees (and one or two directors) are probably a tadge embarrassed.

Whoever said that it’s no fun being an employment lawyer? Hey Ho, only 11.5 month until next Christmas. I can’t wait!